The same cover, two very different cash positions
At the start of cover, annual payment removes £400 from the bank account; monthly payments in our illustrative no-deposit schedule leave the £400 available and cost £36.75 each month, £441 in total. The extra £41 is 10.25% of the £400 premium, not a calculated APR. The FCA’s 2026 premium-finance study says monthly insurance is important for access to cover and declined to impose a price cap or mandate interest-free finance. It also found both interest-bearing and 0%-APR models.
My argument is not that a savings account will beat finance. It is that a cash shortfall can arrive before the twelfth instalment.