The same £5,000, three different outcomes
For a free personal current account plus an easy-access saver, the choice is Chase if you will use its cashback, Monzo if you need its budgeting workflow, or Starling if you withdraw cash abroad regularly. None is a reason to leave savings rates unchecked after a promotional period.
Here are the Chase boosted saver, Monzo Instant Access Savings and Starling Easy Saver advertised AERs, checked 4 November 2026. These are saver rates, not current-account interest. Chase's 4.50% includes a fixed 2.25-percentage-point boost for 12 months (open within 31 days of joining); its underlying 2.25% variable rate can change. Starling's 4.00% includes a 1.50-point bonus for six months on the first £25,000; its underlying rate is 2.50% variable. Monzo's free-plan savings rate is 2.75% variable, not the up-to-3.50% paid-plan headline.
Matched example: one adult, £5,000 deposited at the start, untouched for 12 months, free account at each bank, no tax or rate changes; eligible for the introductory offers where applicable. At unchanged quoted rates Chase's 4.50% AER implies £225 over a full year; Monzo's 2.75% implies £137.50. For Starling the six-month bonus means two successive half-years, approximately £5,000 × [(1.04 × 1.025)^0.5 − 1] = £162.36. This uses AER to approximate two half-year holding periods, not an offer of a guaranteed return. Chase leads by roughly £62.64 on interest alone; after its boost expires the ranking reverses if all underlying rates stay unchanged. Check the rate in-app before opening: all three base rates are variable.