GE
GiltEdgeUK Personal Finance

Port or redeem when moving? Why I would pay the ERC for a two-year fix

Share:

Key Takeaways

  • Matched 24-month cash flows make the second-year reset decisive, not the monthly payment alone.
  • At 6.24% in year two, the illustrative new fix wins by £1,276.72 after £2,000 ERC; at 5.29% the port wins by £563.11.
  • Check a written new mortgage offer and the old lender’s porting rules before redeeming.

I would pay the £2,000 early repayment charge to lock a new two-year fix if the written new-deal and old-lender offers match the scenario below. Porting protects just 12 months of this household’s old rate; the purchase obliges them to fund the house beyond that date. A cheap first year is not the same as a cheap two years.

This is a conditional case, not a claim that 5.29% is available to everyone. The case for porting the same household is stronger if the old lender can refinance cheaply next year or the chain fails. Compare the entire period before paying to leave.

The matched household and the new fix

One household, two choices (illustration, not an offer): sell a £300,000 home with £200,000 outstanding, use all £100,000 equity as deposit on a £300,000 replacement, and borrow £200,000 again (66.7% LTV). The repayment term has 20 years left; the existing fix has 12 months left at an assumed contractual 6.00%, with an assumed 1% (£2,000) ERC on full redemption. Compare 24 months from completion, with no top-up. The new-deal illustration uses HSBC’s 70% LTV two-year Fee Saver at 5.29%, £0 booking fee, shown on its moving-home rate table when checked 15 November 2026. This is not a personalised quote or a claim that HSBC will accept this application. Both routes have the same property, equity, repayment term and moving costs; property tax, valuation and legal fees common to both are excluded. Neither route assumes overpayments or a rate change in the first 12 months.

HSBC’s rate table shows the quoted 5.29% fee-free 70% LTV moving-home product and its listed 6.24% variable follow-on rate; the 6.00% existing fix and £2,000 ERC are assumptions, not HSBC quotes. Bank Rate was 4.00% after the 5 November 2026 change; it is not a substitute for either mortgage offer.

Pay £2,000 once; control the second year

Monthly repayment is £1,432.86 on the old 6.00% fix and £1,352.16 on the new 5.29% fix (both £200,000 over 240 months). After 12 payments, old-fix interest totals £11,854.75, versus £10,441.08 on the new fix: the £1,413.67 first-year interest saving does not recover the £2,000 ERC. At month 12, the ported balance is £194,660.40 and the new-loan balance is £194,215.14. If the ported loan then reprices to an assumed 6.24% for the next 12 months, with 228 months remaining, its new monthly payment is £1,459.61. Across the two years, porting costs £23,845.33 interest; redeeming costs £20,568.61 interest plus £2,000 ERC. Redeeming is £1,276.72 cheaper on interest plus ERC; its remaining balance is also £1,018.95 lower. Compare interest plus ERC, not just monthly payments: principal repayment is your equity, not a cost. Rounding shown to the nearest penny; chart rounds to pounds.

The gap is not a forecast of savings: it is a test of a second-year repricing. In the first year alone the ERC outweighs interest saved by £586.33. By month 24, if the ported loan resets to 6.24%, the new fix has overtaken it by £1,276.72 on interest plus ERC. A two-year fix also removes the need to refinance during the first year in the new property. That has value to a household whose income or home valuation may change, even though it cannot be expressed as a guaranteed cash saving.

What rate makes this argument collapse?

The 6.24% in year two is not a forecast or the existing lender’s quoted follow-on rate. It is a sensitivity input matching the variable follow-on rate displayed beside HSBC’s two-year products on the rate table on 15 November 2026. The old lender’s actual offer, fees, valuation and affordability decision can change the answer. If the ported loan instead gets a 5.29% fee-free fix from month 13, its second-year interest is £10,150.75; total port interest becomes £22,005.50, £563.11 less than the new deal’s interest plus ERC. Seek written offers for both routes, including what happens after the existing fix ends.

The £3,276.72 difference in 24-month interest is the maximum ERC that the new fix could absorb in the 6.24% reset scenario before other differential fees. The real ERC comes from the redemption statement, not a generic lender percentage. Compare cash paid and balance remaining separately; a lower monthly repayment by itself is not enough. Try changing the term in the mortgage calculator.

Porting can fail even with an attractive rate

Nationwide explains that a port moves the mortgage product, not the existing debt; it requires a fresh application and current underwriting. The like-for-like £200,000 move avoids a top-up in this example, but a more expensive house would require a second borrowing tranche at another rate, while a smaller mortgage can trigger an ERC on the unported portion. Halifax says a failed or delayed purchase after sale can mean paying ERC first and only possibly getting a refund. Nationwide specifies a 180-day window after paying off the old mortgage for its own product; do not assume that deadline or refund applies to another lender.

The downside of my approach: if the house purchase collapses before the old loan is redeemed, the proposed new loan does not complete and the ERC in this model is not paid; if you sell first and redeem anyway, you may pay it without having a replacement property. Confirm timing with your conveyancer. Do not surrender a portable rate before a viable chain and new mortgage offer are in place.

Decision: price certainty, not rate nostalgia

Ask both lenders for written illustrations at the same LTV and term, plus a redemption figure and the exact end date of the old fix. If the new two-year fix has meaningful booking or valuation fees, add those to the £2,000 before using the threshold. See the porting process guide and the mortgages hub. If the old lender offers a cheap year-two refinance without fees, take the other side of this debate: port.

Conclusion

Under the stated 6.24% second-year assumption, redeeming buys two-year certainty and a £1,276.72 cost advantage after the hypothetical ERC. At 5.29% for the port’s second year, I would not pay to exit: porting is £563.11 cheaper. The port-first argument deserves equal weight when you have a good refinancing offer or a fragile chain.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. You should seek independent financial advice before making any investment decisions. Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

Sources

Related Topics

port mortgage when movingmortgage early repayment chargeport or remortgage

Related Articles

Enjoyed this article?
Share:

This article is based on publicly available UK economic and financial data. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute regulated financial advice. GiltEdge is not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Always consult a qualified financial adviser before making investment or financial planning decisions.