Five banks, but four banking groups — because HSBC and First Direct share HSBC Group. The HSBC vs First Direct decision is the first choice you make, and it shapes everything else. Here is the optimal sequence for July 2026.
The HSBC vs First Direct decision
Pick HSBC (£220) if you want the highest cash bonus and do not use an overdraft. You forfeit First Direct's £250 0% overdraft and 7% regular saver. A basic-rate taxpayer with no overdraft comes out £20 ahead with HSBC.
Pick First Direct (£200) if you use an overdraft — the £250 0% facility saves roughly £100 in interest over the year. Add the 7% regular saver (£300/month, ~£136 in interest) and the total value of the First Direct package exceeds HSBC's £220 by a wide margin. First Direct also wins on service quality.
Take First Direct. The £20 cash difference is dwarfed by the overdraft and saver value for anyone carrying even a modest overdraft balance.
Step 1: Open a donor account (if needed). Most people already have a current account to switch from. If your only account is the one your salary lands in and you want to keep it, open a second basic account — Monzo and Starling open in minutes — and switch that one instead. You need at least two active direct debits on the donor account. Set up two £1 direct debits to charities (British Heart Foundation, Shelter, RNLI) — they activate within days.
Step 2: Barclays first (£200). The offer runs to 27 August 2026 — start here because it has a hard deadline. Pay in £2,000 — this can be salary, not a separate lump sum. Two direct debits. Paid within 28 working days.
Step 3: NatWest second (£200 + rewards). Once the Barclays bonus lands, switch to a NatWest Reward account. £1,250 pay-in within 60 days. The £4/month direct debit reward plus £1/month app login reward means £60/year minus the £24 annual fee (£2/month), netting £36/year from rewards. The 6% Digital Regular Saver (£150/month) adds approximately £58 in interest over 12 months. Bonus paid within 30 days.
Step 4: First Direct third (£200 + overdraft + saver). Switch the NatWest account to First Direct. £1,000 pay-in. The £250 0% overdraft costs nothing to have, even if you never use it. The 7% regular saver (£300/month) is the best linked rate on the market. Paid within 28 days.
Step 5: Santander fourth (£180 + £45 Amazon voucher). Switch the First Direct account to Santander. The £45 Amazon voucher is effectively cash for most households. Consider keeping this one: Santander Edge's 1% bills cashback (up to £10/month, £120/year) plus the cashback on spending makes it a strong ongoing account. There is a £3/month Edge fee, so net cashback is £84/year after the fee.
Total first-year value: £200 (Barclays) + £200 (NatWest) + £200 (First Direct) + £180 (Santander) + £45 (Amazon voucher) + £36 (NatWest net rewards) + £58 (NatWest regular saver) + £136 (First Direct regular saver) = £1,055.
Realistically, you will not max every regular saver for the full year while rotating accounts. A conservative estimate: £800 in bonuses + £45 voucher + £50 in rewards and saver interest over the holding periods = ~£895. Tax due: £0 for almost everyone.
What you give up: Four hard credit searches (typically 5–10 points each, recovering within 3–6 months). If you are applying for a mortgage, car finance, or any significant credit before January 2027, limit yourself to one or two switches or delay the exercise. Four searches in a year is fine for a healthy credit file; four in a month is not.
This strategy works because the 'new customer' restriction is per-banking-group, and we are targeting four separate FSCS authorisations: Barclays, NatWest Group, HSBC Group (First Direct), and Santander. You are accepting four separate invitations from four separate institutions.
For joint account strategies and how couples can double the take, see our joint bank accounts guide.