Four renewals have a hurdle, not a guarantee
How the figures work. We assume the annual-interest option, interest retained and compounded at the stated AER, and a constant 40% tax rate on all interest over five years (the allowance is assumed used elsewhere throughout). HMRC's 2026/27 income-tax table lists 40% for the higher-rate band outside Scotland; actual tax bands and allowances can change. For each year, calculate interest as opening account balance × that year's rate, add it to the balance, then deduct 40% of that interest from household wealth, not from the locked bond: taxes are assumed paid from separate cash. The five-year figure is gross closing bond balance less the sum of nominal tax bills. This excludes the return that external tax cash could otherwise have earned, and assumes no change in tax law; it is not an after-tax account statement. On the five-year fix, £20,000 × 1.0525⁵ = £25,830.96 gross; interest £5,830.96, illustrative tax £2,332.38, net economic value £23,498.57. For the one-year path, fix 4.78% in year one, then hypothetically obtain the same stated renewal rate in each of years two to five: at 4%, gross £24,515.56 / net £22,709.33; at 4.78%, gross £25,259.34 / net £23,155.60; at 6%, gross £26,456.47 / net £23,873.88. These renewal rates are scenarios, not products on sale or forecasts. Rounded chart values represent these same net amounts. The repeat rate that equalises the outcomes is approximately 5.37% in each of the four renewals, found from (1.0525⁵ / 1.0478)^(1/4) − 1. Taxes cannot change that break-even in this model because both paths apply the same tax percentage to all interest.
If one-year renewals remain at today's quoted 4.78%, the long fix is ahead by £342.97 after the same illustrative tax. If they reset at 4%, the gap becomes £789.24. Four renewals at a hypothetical 6% beat the long fix by £375.31. None of those numbers is a forecast. The 5.37% break-even is above both the initial one-year offer and the long offer: waiting for exactly today's five-year rate to show up as a one-year renewal would still not quite compensate for the cheaper first year.