Cash vs Stocks and Shares: The £115,000 Question
A Junior ISA comes in two flavours: cash and stocks and shares. Your child can hold one of each simultaneously, and the combined limit is £9,000 per tax year for 2025/26.
The choice matters enormously over an 18-year time horizon. Here's the maths on depositing £9,000 annually into each type:
The cash JISA at the current best rate of 3.85% produces roughly £64,000 in interest over 18 years. The stocks and shares JISA, assuming a 7% long-term equity return (the FTSE All-Share has averaged roughly this over any 18-year rolling period since 1986), generates approximately £179,000 in growth. That's a £115,000 difference — and the entire sum is tax-free regardless of which type you choose.
The counterargument is obvious: stocks and shares can fall. Your child's JISA could be worth less than you deposited at any given moment. But the crucial factor is time. With an 18-year horizon, your child's investment would have survived every major crash in modern history and still beaten cash by a wide margin. The 2008 financial crisis, the 2020 pandemic crash, the 2022 rate shock — an 18-year-old in 2026 whose parents invested at birth rode through all three.
The real risk isn't volatility. It's inflation. Cash at 3.85% looks comfortable today, but with the Bank of England base rate at 3.75% and rates trending downward, that cash JISA rate will fall. After inflation, your child's purchasing power barely grows. Equities have historically outpaced inflation by 4-5 percentage points annually.