Start with the £200-a-month test
Assume a £4,000 balance moves immediately, with the percentage transfer fee added to the new balance, no new spending, and £200 paid at the end of each month. Each comparison starts on the same day. At 0%, the Barclaycard 12-month, 0%-fee offer needs £333.34 a month to clear £4,000 within the promotional window (the last payment is slightly smaller). £200 leaves £1,600 after month 12.
The Barclaycard up-to-22-month offer charges 1.49%: £59.60 on £4,000, bringing the starting debt to £4,059.60. At £200 a month you pay it off in month 21, with a final payment of £59.60. HSBC's up-to-36-month offer costs 3.09%, or £123.60, and also clears in month 21 at the same monthly budget. The extra £64 buys unused time. These are advertised up to periods, not a promise of acceptance.
The chart uses issuer-advertised fees and periods checked 21 October 2026. Its 12-month interest is a scenario, not the card's quoted balance-transfer reversion rate: it assumes 24.9% nominal annually, charged monthly at 24.9%/12 on the balance outstanding after the promotion; £200 is then paid at each month-end. Actual interest accrues daily and your personalised rate may differ.